Should you refinance your mortgage? Yes — if the monthly saving repays the closing costs before you sell or pay off the loan. On a $400,000 mortgage, refinancing from 6.5% to 5.5% on a new 30-year term cuts the payment from $2,528.27 to $2,271.16 a month, a saving of $257.11. With $6,000 in closing costs, you break even after 24 months — stay longer than that and refinancing wins; leave sooner and it loses.
That one comparison — break-even time versus how long you will keep the loan — is the whole decision. Everything else in this guide is how to work it out for your own numbers, and the trap that catches people who only look at the lower payment.
What Does It Mean to Refinance a Mortgage?
Refinancing means replacing your current mortgage with a brand-new loan, usually at a lower interest rate. The new lender pays off your old balance, and you start over with new terms: a new rate, a new monthly payment, and — this is the part people forget — a brand-new loan term.
Refinancing is not free. Lenders charge closing costs, typically 2% to 6% of the loan amount, for the appraisal, title search, origination fee, and other charges. On a $400,000 loan, $6,000 in closing costs is 1.5% — on the low side, and still enough to matter. You pay those costs in cash at closing or roll them into the new loan balance, which means paying interest on them for decades. So refinancing is a trade: a lump sum now in exchange for a smaller payment every month. Whether it is worth it depends on two numbers only — how much you save each month, and how many months you will keep the new loan.
The Break-Even Formula: The Only Calculation That Matters
Here is the formula, step by step:
Step 1: Work out your current monthly payment. For our example, a $400,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years costs $2,528.27 a month in principal and interest.
Step 2: Work out the new monthly payment. The same $400,000 at 5.5% over 30 years costs $2,271.16 a month. You can check any rate with a free mortgage amortization calculator.
Step 3: Subtract to find the monthly saving. $2,528.27 − $2,271.16 = $257.11 a month.
Step 4: Add up the closing costs. In our example, $6,000.
Step 5: Divide the closing costs by the monthly saving. $6,000 ÷ $257.11 = 23.3 months. Round up: you break even after 24 months.
That is the break-even point. Before month 24, refinancing has cost you more than it saved. After month 24, every month’s $257.11 is pure saving. The rule is simple: refinance only if you are confident you will keep the loan past the break-even month.
Worked Example: Refinancing $400,000 from 6.5% to 5.5%
Here is the full comparison for our example loan — $400,000, refinanced from 6.5% to 5.5% on a new 30-year term, with $6,000 in closing costs:
| Current loan (6.5%) | New loan (5.5%) | |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | $400,000 | $400,000 |
| Monthly payment | $2,528.27 | $2,271.16 |
| Monthly saving | — | $257.11 |
| Total interest over 30 years | $510,177.95 | $417,616.16 |
| Total interest saved | — | $92,561.79 |
| Closing costs | — | $6,000 |
| Net saving (interest saved minus closing costs) | — | $86,561.79 |
| Break-even point | — | 24 months |
If you keep the new loan for the full 30 years, refinancing saves $86,561.79 after closing costs. If you sell or refinance again after 12 months, you have saved 12 × $257.11 = $3,085.32 but paid $6,000 to get it — a loss of $2,914.68. The same refinance is a great deal or a bad deal depending only on how long you stay.
The table below shows the same $400,000 loan refinanced at different rates, all with $6,000 in closing costs:
| New rate | New payment | Monthly saving | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.25% | $2,462.87 | $65.40 | 92 months (7.7 years) |
| 6.0% | $2,398.20 | $130.07 | 47 months (3.9 years) |
| 5.5% | $2,271.16 | $257.11 | 24 months (2 years) |
| 5.0% | $2,147.29 | $380.98 | 16 months (1.3 years) |
A quarter-point drop saves only $65.40 a month and takes nearly eight years to break even — longer than many people stay in one home. That is why the old rule of thumb says to wait for at least a full percentage point drop before refinancing. Check your own numbers on a mortgage amortization schedule first.
The Amortization-Reset Trap: Why Refinancing Late Can Cost You Money
Here is the trap. Refinancing restarts the amortization clock. A 30-year mortgage front-loads interest: in month 1 of our example loan, $2,166.67 of the $2,528.27 payment is interest and only $361.61 reduces the balance. Refinance after several years and you throw away that progress, going back to paying almost all interest again.
Take the same borrower five years into the loan. The balance is now $374,443.91, with 300 payments left. If they keep the old loan, the remaining interest is 300 × $2,528.27 − $374,443.91 = $384,037.09. Now suppose they refinance that $374,443.91 balance into a new 30-year loan at 5.5%:
| Keep the old loan | Refinance at 5.5% (new 30 years) | |
|---|---|---|
| Balance | $374,443.91 | $374,443.91 |
| Monthly payment | $2,528.27 | $2,126.05 |
| Monthly saving | — | $402.22 |
| Payments remaining | 300 (25 years) | 360 (30 years) |
| Total interest remaining | $384,037.09 | $390,934.57 |
| Closing costs | $0 | $6,000 |
| Net result | — | $12,897.48 worse |
The payment drops by $402.22 a month — it feels like a win. But the new loan charges $390,934.57 in interest, which is $6,897.48 more than the remaining interest on the old loan, because the clock restarts and the loan runs five years longer. Add the $6,000 in closing costs, and this refinance loses $12,897.48 overall — despite the lower rate and the lower payment.
The lesson: a lower payment is not the same as a lower cost. Always compare total interest remaining, not just the monthly payment. The fix is simple: if you refinance partway through a loan, refinance into a term that matches what is left — in this case, a 25-year term — instead of restarting at 30 years.
When Does Refinancing Save Money?
Refinancing is usually a good deal when most of these are true:
- The rate drop is at least 1 percentage point. At that size, the monthly saving repays typical closing costs in about two years.
- You will stay past the break-even month. If your break-even is 24 months and you plan to stay at least five years, the margin is comfortable. If you might move in 18 months, do not refinance.
- You are early in the loan. In the first few years, most of your payment is still interest, so restarting the clock costs little. Late in the loan, most of your payment is principal, and restarting is expensive.
- Your credit score has improved. A better score can mean a lower rate than the market average — sometimes the refinance is worth it even when rates in general have not fallen.
- You are not stretching the term to chase a lower payment. A longer term always lowers the payment and raises the total cost. Compare total interest, not the monthly number.
What About the Closing Costs — Pay Cash or Roll Them In?
You have two ways to pay the $6,000 in closing costs, and they are not equal:
- Pay cash at closing. The loan stays at $400,000, the payment is $2,271.16, and total interest is $417,616.16. Net saving versus the old loan: $86,561.79.
- Roll the costs into the loan. The new loan becomes $406,000. The payment is $2,305.22 — still $223.05 less than the old payment — and total interest is $423,880.40. You pay interest on the $6,000 in fees for 30 years, which adds $6,264.24 to their cost.
Rolling the costs in feels free because nothing leaves your bank account at closing, but it costs $6,264.24 more over the loan’s life. If you can pay cash, do.
What About Refinancing to a 15-Year Term?
Refinancing into a shorter term is a different decision from refinancing for a lower payment. The same $400,000 refinanced to 5.5% over 15 years costs $3,268.33 a month — $740.06 more than the current $2,528.27 — but total interest is only $188,300.09, saving $321,877.86 versus the old 30-year loan. That is the trade in the other direction: a higher payment now for far less interest overall. Our guide to the 15-year vs 30-year mortgage compares the two terms in full.
Another way to get the same effect without refinancing at all is to pay extra on the current loan. Adding $200 a month pays it off in 293 months instead of 360 and saves $111,891.54 in interest, with no closing costs and no new loan — and biweekly mortgage payments are another no-fee way to cut years off the loan.
A Faster Way to Check Your Numbers
The break-even formula is simple, but it only works with exact numbers for your loan — your balance, your rate, your closing-cost quote. Run your own figures through Calcrio’s free amortization calculator to see the payment, the total interest, and the full month-by-month schedule for any rate and term before you sign anything.
FAQ: Should I Refinance My Mortgage?
Should I refinance my mortgage?
Refinance if the monthly saving repays the closing costs before you sell or pay off the loan. On a $400,000 mortgage, refinancing from 6.5% to 5.5% saves $257.11 a month and breaks even in 24 months with $6,000 in closing costs — so it pays off if you stay longer than two years.
How do I calculate the refinance break-even point?
Divide the total closing costs by the monthly payment saving. For example, $6,000 in closing costs divided by a $257.11 monthly saving equals 23.3 months, so you break even after 24 months.
How much does it cost to refinance a mortgage?
Closing costs are typically 2% to 6% of the loan amount, covering appraisal, origination, title, and other fees. On a $400,000 loan that is $8,000 to $24,000 at the standard range, though our example uses $6,000 (1.5%).
Does refinancing restart my mortgage?
Yes. A new 30-year refinance starts a brand-new 30-year clock, which means you go back to paying mostly interest in the early years. If you are five years into a loan, refinancing the $374,443.91 balance into a new 30-year term at 5.5% actually costs $12,897.48 more overall, despite the lower payment.
Is refinancing worth it for a 1% rate drop?
Usually yes, if you will stay past break-even. A 1-point drop from 6.5% to 5.5% on $400,000 saves $257.11 a month and breaks even in 24 months with $6,000 in closing costs, for a net saving of $86,561.79 over the full term. A quarter-point drop, by contrast, saves only $65.40 a month and takes 92 months to break even.
Word count: ~1,640
Numbers verified: Python-verified 2026-11-15 — base $400,000/6.5%/30yr: payment $2,528.27, total interest $510,177.95; refi at 5.5%: payment $2,271.16, saving $257.11/mo, break-even $6,000/$257.11 = 23.3 → 24 months, new total interest $417,616.16, gross saving $92,561.79, net $86,561.79; rate table (6.25% $2,462.87/$65.40/92 mo; 6.0% $2,398.20/$130.07/47 mo; 5.0% $2,147.29/$380.98/16 mo); after-5-yrs reset: balance $374,443.91, remaining old interest $384,037.09, new 30yr at 5.5% payment $2,126.05, new interest $390,934.57, $6,897.48 more interest + $6,000 closing = $12,897.48 worse; rolled-in $406,000 loan: payment $2,305.22, total interest $423,880.40, $6,264.24 extra; 15yr refi at 5.5%: payment $3,268.33, interest $188,300.09, saves $321,877.86; +$200/mo extra: 293 months, saves $111,891.54.
